Sully's Island | Café & Bar

Single-Origin Espresso. Craft Cocktails. One Unforgettable Address.

From the first pull of the morning pour-over to the last twist of the evening martini — Sully's Island is where Ashland comes to savor something real.

Open Daily 7 AM – 11 PM

8 Elmer St, Ashland, PA 17921

Built on the belief that a great drink is an experience, not just an order.

Sully's Island started as a corner conversation — what if a café could feel as intentional as a cocktail bar, and a bar could welcome the morning crowd with the same warmth? We opened our doors on Elmer Street with that question, and Ashland answered.

Every pour-over is sourced from roasters we know by name. Every cocktail is shaken to order with house-made infusions and spirits selected for character, not margin. Whether you're here at 8 AM with a newspaper or 9 PM with good company, the standard doesn't change.

12+ Single-Origin Coffee Rotations

40+ Craft Cocktails on Rotation

Local Sourced Ingredients & Spirits

Espresso Double shot, our house blend — rich, chocolatey, balanced
Caffè Latte Espresso with steamed milk and a thin layer of microfoam
Cappuccino Equal parts espresso, steamed milk, and velvety foam
Flat White Double ristretto with silky microfoam — stronger, smoother
Americano Espresso diluted with hot water — bold and clean

Ethiopian Yirgacheffe Jasmine, bergamot, and stone fruit — bright and tea-like
Colombian Huila Caramel, red apple, and a nutty finish — smooth and round
Guatemalan Antigua Dark chocolate, cocoa, and a hint of smokiness

Honey Lavender Latte Local honey, lavender syrup, oat milk optional
Cold Brew 18-hour steep, served over hand-cut ice — smooth and low-acid
Matcha Ceremony Ceremonial-grade matcha, whisked to order, your choice of milk

The Island Mule Bourbon, house ginger cordial, lime, top with premium ginger beer
Smoked Old Fashioned Rye whiskey, demerara, Angostura bitters, smoked tableside with cherry wood
Elmer Street Sour Bourbon, lemon, egg white, absinthe rinse — our namesake
Midnight Martini Gin or vodka, dry vermouth, olive brine, black olive garnish

House Red Pinot Noir or Cabernet — rotating selection from small vineyards
House White Chardonnay or Sauvignon Blanc — crisp, seasonal, always chilled
Craft Beer on Tap Local and regional taps — ask for today's selection

Avocado Toast Sourdough, smashed avocado, radish, microgreens, everything seasoning
Eggs Benedict Poached eggs, house ham, hollandaise, English muffin
Breakfast Burrito Scrambled eggs, cheese, salsa, sour cream in a warm tortilla
Greek Yogurt Bowl Local yogurt, granola, seasonal fruit, honey drizzle

Charcuterie Board Cured meats, aged cheeses, house pickles, crackers
Soup of the Day Made from scratch — ask your server for today's recipe
Grilled Cheese Three-cheese blend on sourdough, tomato soup on the side

Butter Croissant Laminated, flaky, baked fresh every morning
Seasonal Fruit Tart Pastry cream, shortcrust, market-fresh fruit
Chocolate Mousse Dark chocolate, whipped cream, sea salt — rich and airy

We're on Elmer Street.

Right in the heart of Ashland, Sully's Island is easy to find and even easier to love. Walk in anytime during our hours — no reservation needed for the bar, though we recommend one for weekend evenings.

Address

8 Elmer St, Ashland, PA 17921-9003

Phone

(157) 055-5555

Hours

Mon–Thu: 7 AM – 10 PM
Fri–Sat: 7 AM – 11 PM
Sun: 8 AM – 9 PM

Reservations

Recommended for weekend evenings. Call or use the form below.

Single-Origin Espresso. Craft Cocktails. One Unforgettable Address.

Built on the belief that a great drink is an experience, not just an order.

Two worlds. One counter.

Espresso Classics

Single-Origin Pour-Over

Specialty & Seasonal

Signature Cocktails

Wine & Beer

Non-Alcoholic

Breakfast & Brunch

Small Plates

Pastries & Sweets

Step inside.

We're on Elmer Street.

Reserve a Table

Reservation Requested!